Feature Request: Render Client Tray Application

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • 22nd December 2007 at 1:37 am #14224

    Hi,

    In earlier versions of Muster, there used to be the ability for people whose machines were used as Render Clients, to open the Render Client manager and quickly do a “Kill And Pause” or “Resume”.

    In 5.31, this ability has disappeared, as all machines are managed centrally. I understand the design philosophy of managing render clients centrally, and that’s a good thing.

    But you are also misunderstanding the user demographic, as it is quite common to use every PC in the building as a render client and leave them on 24/7. During the day, these workstations are used for regular business, at night they render.

    It’s neither safe or appropriate to start giving a receptionist or an accountant access to Muster Explorer, so that they can turn their own computer on or off as a render node.

    I think that you need to write a tiny and dedicated tray application that is idiot-proof, where people can quickly select their computer’s status, such as Active, Pause, Kill And Pause. You could possibly also make an availability detector that reenables a render client after a preset amount of inactivity (i.e. 20 minutes or 30 minutes). This could then open a floating window in the middle of the screen alerting the user that the machine is now being used as a render node, giving people the option to Kill And Pause.

    The important part is that on a big job, everyone’s computer will be used for rendering, but many of those people don’t even know what rendering is, let alone know what to do inside Muster Explorer. I think you need to write an interface allowing people to control their computer’s status without requiring them to be a network administrator as well.

    Someone who is a power user would simply opt to not have this tray application installed on his computer. Power users can control their computer through Muster Explorer. Everyone else can control their computer through a friendly and simple tray application.

    Thanks,

    Per

    1st January 2008 at 1:35 am #14768

    You’re right. We have looked at putting the tray application back in action. In the upcoming 5.4, there’s already a tray icon for Macintosh that acts as a one-shot installer and service control.
    Plans are to expand it to windows and give the applet ability to local control the renderclient.

    11th January 2008 at 12:30 am #14778

    Hi,

    I’ll hope that you’ll design this tray-application specifically for people who don’t really know a lot of Muster. For example, I’ve been installing CPU meters on computers around the house for the sole purpose of people knowing IF their computer is currently rendering or not.

    That’s why I suggested above to literally open a window on top of all others saying that this computer is currently being used for rendering. That is the sort of hand-holding the non-technical folks need. To ask them to open a Task Manager to look at the CPU usage and then go into a tray application or Muster Explorer to change the node state, is WAY too much to ask them to do.

    So I’ll hope that you’ll make an application that will tell people up-front IF their computer is currently rendering, and HOW to turn it off. Don’t require people to open anything or read any funny numbers. Make it really, really, really easy.

    Best,

    Per

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.